Baking1 hr 15 minHoney-Boiled Bagels
Honey-water boiled, baked hot, and smaller and sweeter than most.
A lean, slightly sweet dough boiled in honey water, then baked hot until dark and crisp with a chewy, dense crumb. Smaller, thinner and sweeter than the bakery standard, with a bigger hole.
- Prep
- 30 min
- Cook
- 25 min
- Total
- 55 min
- Makes
- 12 bagels

The background
Where this dish comes from
The honey-boiled bagel began in the early 1900s with Jewish immigrants from Eastern Europe, and it survives in a handful of bakeries that have been arguing about the details for decades. Three things set it apart: the water is sweetened with honey rather than malt, the bake is fierce and dry, and the dough contains egg and oil for a softer, richer crumb. Home ovens cannot replicate a wood fire, but a very hot oven and a pizza stone get close.
Editorial note
This recipe was developed and tested in the Butterlark kitchen. We publish no AI-written recipes and no copied methods; read our testing policy. Last updated 6 December 2025.
Ingredients
12 servingsTap a line to cross it off as you go.
Dough
Boiling & topping
To serve
Equipment
- Stand mixer with dough hook
- Large wide pan for boiling
- Pizza stone or heavy baking tray
- Slotted spoon
- Wire rack
Switching to cups converts weights using standard cup densities. For baking, grams are always the more accurate measure — use them if you have a scale.
Method
7 stepsRead it once, then use cook mode so your screen stays awake.
- 1
Mix and knead the dough
Combine the flour, yeast, salt and sugar. Add the egg, oil and water and knead 8–10 minutes until smooth, stiff and slightly tacky. Bagel dough is much firmer than bread dough — resist adding water.
10 min timer
- 2
Bulk ferment
Cover and leave at room temperature 60–90 minutes until roughly doubled. If you have time, refrigerate overnight instead for better flavour.
1 hr 15 min timer
- 3
Shape the rings
Divide into 12 pieces of about 70 g. Roll each into a 20 cm rope and wrap it around your hand, overlapping the ends and rolling the seam on the counter to seal. Or poke a hole through a ball and widen it to 3 cm. These bagels want a generous hole.
- 4
Second rise
Place on a lined tray, cover, and prove 20–30 minutes until slightly puffy. Do not over-prove — bagels should go into the water still firm.
25 min timer
- 5
Boil in honey water
Heat the water with the honey and bicarbonate to a gentle simmer. Boil the bagels 45 seconds a side — no longer. They will puff and float. Lift out with a slotted spoon and drain briefly on a rack.
3 min timer
- 6
Top and bake hot
Dip the tops in sesame seeds and place on a hot pizza stone or tray. Bake at 240°C / 465°F for 14–18 minutes, turning once, until dark golden and glossy. They are meant to be darker than you expect.
16 min timer
- 7
Cool on a rack
Cool 20 minutes before eating — the crumb is still setting. Best eaten the same day, ideally still warm, split by hand and never with a knife.
20 min timer
Cooking this now? Cook mode keeps the screen on, one step at a time.
Cook's notes
Three things that make the difference
- 1
Stiff dough, short boil, hot oven. Those three things, in that order, make a bagel rather than a bread roll.
- 2
Never bake on a cold tray. A preheated stone or an upside-down heavy tray gives the bottom crust that wood-oven snap.
- 3
Split bagels by hand with a fork or your fingers. A knife compresses the crumb.
Variations worth trying
Everything bagels
Mix sesame, poppy, dried garlic, dried onion and coarse salt and press the boiled bagel tops into it. The old bakeries do this and it is the best version.
Wholemeal version
Replace 150 g of the white flour with wholemeal and add 20 ml extra water. Bake 2 minutes longer.
Storing & reheating
Best the day they are made. Keep 2 days in a paper bag at room temperature; never refrigerate — it makes them stale fast. Freeze sliced for 3 months and toast from frozen.
Nutrition
per serving| Calories | 250 kcal |
|---|---|
| Protein | 8 g |
| Carbohydrate | 42 g |
| Fat | 5 g |
| Fibre | 2 g |
| Sugar | 4 g |
| Sodium | 320 mg |
Estimated from standard ingredient databases, based on 12 servings. Figures are a guide, not medical advice.
Liked this one?
Get next Sunday's recipe by email
One tested dish from a different kitchen every week, plus the printable list.
Troubleshooting
Honey-Boiled Bagels questions
What makes these bagels different from a bakery-standard bagel?+
Honey in the boiling water instead of malt, egg and oil in the dough, a very hot dry bake, and a smaller, thinner, sweeter bagel with a bigger hole.
Why boil bagels at all?+
Boiling sets the crust before baking, which stops the dough from rising further and gives the characteristic dense, chewy interior.
Can I make them without a stand mixer?+
Yes, but the dough is stiff. Knead 15 minutes by hand and rest it 10 minutes halfway through to let the gluten relax.
Keep cooking
More like this
Baking1 hr 15 min
Dessert1 hrButter Tarts
Main24 minMaple-Glazed Salmon
Honey-Boiled Bagels — https://pantry-atlas.vercel.app/recipes/honey-boiled-bagels · © Butterlark
