Skip to content

Editorial standards

How we test every recipe

This page explains exactly how a dish gets from an idea to a published recipe on Butterlark, and what we do when something turns out to be wrong.

Last updated 18 November 2026

1. We start from the traditional version

Before we cook anything, we read what the dish actually is: the accepted construction, older sources, and the version experienced cooks recognise as correct. Shepherd's pie contains lamb. A bowl of red contains no beans. A honey-boiled bagel is dunked, not steamed. We do not “improve” a classic until we can cook the classic properly.

2. Every recipe is cooked at least twice

The first cook is development: quantities are scribbled, timings are off, something usually burns. The second cook is the photographing and timing pass, done exactly as written with a scale and an instant-read thermometer. If the second pass does not match the first, we cook it a third time.

Recipes are only published once a second cook has reproduced the result. Timings in the method are what we actually observed, not what sounds plausible.

3. Weights are primary, cups are converted

Every recipe is authored in grams and millilitres, because that is the only way to bake repeatably. The cup figures are converted using standard ingredient densities — 125 g per cup of plain flour, 200 g per cup of granulated sugar — and the recipe page tells you when a conversion is approximate. If you own a scale, use it.

4. We write the failure modes into the method

A recipe that only tells you what to do is half a recipe. Ours include what goes wrong without each step: why the pastry goes soggy, why the cream splits, why the batter puddings do not rise, why the cheesecake cracks. That is the part that actually makes you a better cook.

5. Nutrition is an estimate and we say so

Nutrition figures are calculated per serving from standard ingredient databases, based on the ingredient list as written. They are a guide, not a laboratory analysis and not medical advice. Substitutions, portion size and brand will all change the numbers.

6. No fake ratings, no invented authors

We do not publish aggregate star ratings from reviews that do not exist, and we do not attach invented expert names to recipes. Our structured data mirrors what is visible on the page — nothing more.

7. Corrections

If you cook something from this site and it does not work, tell us. Email our contact page with the recipe name and what happened. We recook it, and if you are right we amend the recipe and note the change date at the top of the page.