Dessert1 hr 35 minButter Tarts
Runny or firm? The great house-style question, in a pastry shell.
Butter tarts with a flaky pastry shell and a filling of butter, brown sugar, egg and a little vinegar — either runny or firm depending on the cook. Raisins, walnuts or nothing; all three are traditional.
- Prep
- 40 min
- Cook
- 20 min
- Total
- 1 hr
- Makes
- 12 tarts

The background
Where this dish comes from
Butter tarts are an old farmhouse classic, first recorded in the early 1900s. The filling is essentially a sugar pie in miniature, and the divide is real: some kitchens like them firm, others runny enough to drip down your wrist. The vinegar is not a mistake — a teaspoon of acid keeps the filling from becoming cloyingly sweet and helps it set.
Editorial note
This recipe was developed and tested in the Butterlark kitchen. We publish no AI-written recipes and no copied methods; read our testing policy. Last updated 28 December 2025.
Ingredients
12 servingsTap a line to cross it off as you go.
Pastry
Filling
Equipment
- 12-hole muffin tin
- Rolling pin
- Round cutter (10 cm)
- Small jug
- Wire rack
Switching to cups converts weights using standard cup densities. For baking, grams are always the more accurate measure — use them if you have a scale.
Method
6 stepsRead it once, then use cook mode so your screen stays awake.
- 1
Make the pastry
Rub the flour, salt and sugar with the cold butter until it looks like coarse breadcrumbs with some pea-sized lumps left. Add the iced water and vinegar and bring together with a knife, then a hand — do not knead. Flatten into a disc, wrap and chill 45 minutes.
45 min timer
- 2
Line the tins
Roll the pastry 3 mm thick and cut 12 discs of 10 cm. Press gently into the muffin tin holes, easing rather than stretching. Chill 15 minutes while you make the filling.
15 min timer
- 3
Mix the filling
Whisk the melted butter and brown sugar until smooth, then whisk in the eggs, golden syrup, vinegar, vanilla and salt. Do not whip air into it — you want a dense, syrupy filling, not a soufflé.
- 4
Divide and add mix-ins
Scatter a few raisins or walnuts into each shell if using, then pour the filling two-thirds of the way up. Overfilling makes the filling boil over and cement the tarts to the tin.
- 5
Bake hot and brief
Bake at 200°C / 400°F for 15–18 minutes until the pastry is golden and the filling is puffed and bubbling but still wobbly in the centre. For firm tarts, add 3 minutes; for runny, pull them at 15.
17 min timer
- 6
Cool before releasing
Cool in the tin 10 minutes — the filling is molten and will run if you rush. Run a knife around the edge and lift out onto a rack. Best eaten slightly warm.
10 min timer
Cooking this now? Cook mode keeps the screen on, one step at a time.
Cook's notes
Three things that make the difference
- 1
Cold butter, cold water, cold hands. Warm pastry shrinks down the sides of the tin as it bakes.
- 2
Do not overfill. Two-thirds full is the maximum before the filling overflows and glues the tart to the pan.
- 3
The tarts keep setting as they cool, so pull them a minute earlier than you think you should for a runny centre.
Variations worth trying
Maple butter tarts
Replace the golden syrup with dark maple syrup and add ¼ tsp of maple extract. Reduce the brown sugar to 150 g.
Chocolate chip
Scatter 1 tsp of dark chocolate chips into each shell instead of raisins. They sink and form a molten layer under the filling.
Storing & reheating
Keeps 4 days in an airtight tin at room temperature, 1 week refrigerated. Freeze baked tarts for 2 months and refresh at 160°C / 320°F for 8 minutes. Pastry can be frozen raw for 3 months.
Nutrition
per serving| Calories | 280 kcal |
|---|---|
| Protein | 3 g |
| Carbohydrate | 34 g |
| Fat | 15 g |
| Fibre | 1 g |
| Sugar | 22 g |
| Sodium | 130 mg |
Estimated from standard ingredient databases, based on 12 servings. Figures are a guide, not medical advice.
Liked this one?
Get next Sunday's recipe by email
One tested dish from a different kitchen every week, plus the printable list.
Troubleshooting
Butter Tarts questions
Runny or firm — which is correct?+
Both, and both sides are certain. Bake time decides: 15 minutes for runny, 18 for firm.
Raisins or walnuts?+
Raisins are the old-fashioned version; walnuts are common in the baking books of the same era. Plain is also entirely traditional, and arguably the best way to taste the filling.
Why is there vinegar in the filling?+
It balances the sweetness and helps the filling set without becoming candy. One teaspoon, and you will not taste it.
Keep cooking
More like this
Dessert1 hr 35 min
Dessert1 hrLamingtons
Dessert30 minNo-Bake Chocolate Custard Bars
Butter Tarts — https://pantry-atlas.vercel.app/recipes/butter-tarts · © Butterlark
